NAZA and the missing credits
NAZA is an exceptional and historic documentary, not only because of its content but also for what it reveals if you wait until the end of the credit roll in a theater full of viewers. In my recent experience, when the film ended you could hear a pin drop. Hardly a word was spoken the entire time it took the audience to exit the auditorium. A rare occurrence.
What else was there to say when the actions of a government in this century of ours amounted to the mass murder of civilians, aided and abetted by high technology, with clear and calculated intent?
What’s more, if you sit and wait to read the credits until the very end, you might notice that more than one of those credits lists the contributor as “anonymous.” Why? Why would an individual, having put their hard-earned effort into a successfully completed documentary want to remain anonymous? Having one’s name recognized in the credits of a movie, a documentary film or any work of art usually comes with feelings of pride and joy. So why did this one videographer and one editor choose to conceal their names?
The answer to this question becomes apparent as you go through the news articles describing how the Israeli government reacted to NAZA: by labeling the film’s directors as traitors and threatening to remove their citizenship. Again, why?
Is it because the government could prove that the content of the film was inaccurate? Is it because the government could prove that the interviewees were speaking falsehoods? Is it because the government could prove that the intentional targeting of individuals was not premeditated with the use of ruthlessly precise artificial intelligence and surveillance? (For example, the teenage girl whose phone the government tracked to make sure they could kill her father, or the murdered children who happened to be inside a house that was targeted in order to get to the head of the family, their voices heard during the monitoring just prior to the strike.) No. The directors of this brilliant documentary (more later on why I judge it as brilliant) were targeted because they were courageous enough to reveal hard-to-swallow truths. And hard-to-swallow truths are not welcome by governments where singular (and usually nationalistic) narratives are used to brainwash the citizens into a lull of acceptance…at the expense of the truth.[1]
Naza is a brilliant documentary because it documented its facts in an understated manner by interviewing the individuals (albeit disguised) and simply letting their words speak as they openly reveal how they willingly took part in researching, targeting and killing as many civilians as allowed or “expected” with some very precise data analysis and AI. Naza (meaning collateral damage) does happen in wars. But what is examined and exposed in this film is something beyond the unfortunate results of the violence that wars bring to any part of the world. The interviewees openly discuss their sanctioned process (complete with charts and drawings) that helped them target the intended targets as well as the “expected” (and blithely accepted) number of civilians (including women and children) – often in the double or occasionally triple digits – who would become collateral damage with their very own actions.
Naza is a brilliant documentary also in its setting. It uses the rooftops of Tel Aviv to conduct the interviews. While the subjects reveal the intricacies of their actions, we get glimpses of the surrounding residences and office flats, peeking through curtains and window shades to witness ordinary Tel Aviv residents going about their ordinary lives. We can only imagine the horrors experienced in parallel settings just forty-three miles away in Gaza: a government practicing the mass murder of civilians by remote control.[2]
Naza is a brilliant documentary because it does not cater to the overuse of heart-wrenching gore of death and destruction (except for the few poignant minutes towards the end) and yet succeeds in making its point just the same. Even the film’s subtitles seem more impactful, imprinting the extraordinary truths being told as they flash onto the dark spaces between the lighted apartments and offices while the camera pans and tilts across the surrounding buildings.
And despite all of the above reasons for its brilliance, the government of Israel taints that success by targeting its directors, making us think: why would someone who worked on such a documentary choose to remain anonymous? To avoid the same fate as the directors?
We do not know the answer to the latter, but one thing is disturbingly clear: telling the truth is becoming more and more dangerous in our world. As long as governments make it a habit (a dangerous one at that) of sticking to their version of history, regurgitating the same old narrative for their own opportunistic advantages, then writers, journalists, filmmakers and artists will be facing the enormously difficult choice between telling the truth or keeping their sanity, their livelihoods and sometimes even their lives.
In a world tainted by the ills of ethnic hatred, warmongering and the reliance upon artificial intelligence for destructive ends, we are all a bit tainted…until humanity can clearly discern what is moral and what is not.[3]
[1] Note that it took decades for the country of my birth (Turkey/Türkiye) to acknowledge the presence of the Kurds as a distinct ethnic group and to stop referring to them simply as “Mountain Turks.” Also, the Turkish government has not yet recognized the Armenian Genocide of 1915. Also note that the current administration of my adopted country (the United States of America) is working to disprove the official results of the 2020 presidential election as “stolen,” and insists on lessening the significance of racial discrimination as it pertains to the country’s history.
[2] The disturbing nature of this dual atmosphere is reminiscent of the film “The Zone of Interest” that won the Oscar for Best International Feature Film in 2023.
[3] “The state of Israel will prove itself not by material wealth, not by military might or technical achievement, but by its moral character and human values.” David Ben-Gurion (first Prime Minister of the State of Israel)